Sadly, none of those paint chips were the right color. Saturday morning I decided to try a new approach...pick out a color and buy a gallon. Do not bring in samples, just be confident and commit. Obviously my 50 paint chips and sample size cans were not working. I shouldn't be surprised by this, as I have now learned that I am horrible at trying to match colors. And I hate to paint. So naturally I was super frustrated as I stood in front of the paint counter at Lowes on Saturday and tried to get some decent info out of the dude behind the counter. He was useless and apparently my attitude towards him reflected that, as Peter later told me that I was embarrassing. Yeah, sorry about that.
So after analyzing the situation on Friday night, I decided to go back to my original plan and use a neutral color on the walls. With a blue toilet and bathtub, the room has enough blue. And since the only window is in the adjoining laundry room, I wanted to keep the bathroom light and clean looking. So the wall paint is done. Next up is the cabinets and door. Pictures to come soon.